
I was not aware of being a girl for a long time. In her book Bossypants, Tina Fey has a very funny story about the “when did you realize you were a woman?” question, which she uses to talk about victimization, and naturally forces the reader to ask that question of herself. It took me days to settle on an answer, but I did, and here it is.
My second year of college, I was in a David Mamet play called Oleanna. In rehearsal the director was required to explain to me (repeatedly) why a young woman in college would falsify an accusation of attempted rape against a well-meaning professor. This had never happened before, as an actor I mean, because I was an internalist and got along fine making my own character decisions. But in this case my instincts were all wrong, and in the process of correcting my performance the director explained to me what being a woman is. If I may project for a moment, I believe he was more baffled by this need to explain than I was.
The previous year I had played Benvolio in Romeo & Juliet without difficulty. Apparently, at 20 it was more natural for me to play a young man of 16th century Italian gentry than a contemporary college girl.
This illustrates the heart of what makes the new feminism different from its previous incarnations, at least for women like me. I had socially progressive parents who didn’t care about gender norms. I had friends in the goth and theater communities who rejected them outright, in the 90s when androgyny and queerness were the lifeblood of alternative culture. That’s how I made it all the way to 20 with the sensation that my gender had less impact on my identity than my hobbies, my intellect, or my politics. Which is to say, none at all. Aside from the question of hygiene and who would or would not kiss me, I might as well have been a boy.
Of course, I was aware that gender norms existed, it just didn’t occur that they applied to me. Don’t want men to stare at your tits? Then put them away, or better yet, hang out with different guys. Don’t want to get raped? Then don’t get drunk at a frat party, don’t date assholes, don’t act like a helpless kitten all the time. Don’t don’t don’t. But those girls were girls who I hated, because they treated me badly. They treated me badly because shame is the weapons girls use to maintain those same gender norms I thought did not apply to me. I was not like them, they knew it and I knew it, so screw those girls. Clearly my decisions were better than theirs; men stared at my tits only when I wanted them to, and I never attended a party or dated a guy where there appeared even the slightest hint of rape. It hurts now to think about how I thought then, as though there were things a woman could do which relinquish her human rights.
Today my work and my hobbies are all in fields dominated by men: IT, film, and nerd culture. Sexism in these fields have a flavor not unlike the distaste I had for women before I realized I was one, and it is probably the case that my gravitation toward them was largely possible because I was immune to the general anti-feminine miasma in which they are engulfed. Without intention, I obtained my emancipation from sexism by learning to eat my own.
Now that I know better, my next step is not about reaching out to women, but to men. Among young men I know, especially on the internet in nerd and skeptic communities, there seems to be consensus that feminism is an unnecessary vestige from a previous time. It somehow escapes their notice that this consensus has been reached almost entirely among men. The few women within the enclave are by-and-large outside the conversation or do not really identify as women, the way I did not when I was young. Women outside the enclave are dismissed as crazy man-eating bitches. This dynamic alone is sufficient evidence that the problem is real.
Feminism is not dead, but it is different than it was even 10 year ago. It’s not about teaching little girls that they can grow up to be whatever they want, we’ve done that. It’s not just about wage equity or rape statistics, either. It’s about erasing the ideas we have about the way girls are. And the way boys are, too, for that matter.
If I think of a way to do that, I’ll be sure to let you know.
